Skip to content
ParentsParents

Repeating a Year of Kindergarten: 10 Myths and Truths Every Parent Should Know

Little girl playing with a toy camera at nursery

“Should I send him to primary school, or should he stay in kindergarten for another year?”

This is one of the most difficult decisions some parents are faced with. It often comes with anxiety, guilt, social pressure and conflicting advice from relatives, friends or teachers.

Repeating a year of kindergarten is still surrounded by many myths. Yet when it is recommended by specialists after a careful assessment, it is neither a punishment nor a failure. On the contrary, it can be a valuable “gift of time” for the child.

Let’s look at some of the most common myths.

Myth 1: “Repeating a year means failure”

Truth: Repeating a year is not a failure – neither the child’s nor the parents’.

It is not a sign of low intelligence or a lack of ability. It is an educational decision, taken when it is judged that the child needs more time to develop the skills that will help them successfully meet the demands of primary school.

No one would call it a failure to give a child more time to grow. So why should we see it as a failure when it comes to their education?

Myth 2: “He’s old enough, so he should go to primary school”

Truth: School readiness is not determined by age alone.

Two children born in the same year can differ considerably in terms of:

  • language development

  • attention

  • concentration

  • emotional maturity

  • independence

  • social skills

Age is just a number. Readiness is a combination of many factors.

Myth 3: “He’ll lose a year”

Truth: Often the child doesn’t lose time — they gain time.

A child who starts primary school without being truly ready may spend years trying to fill gaps, coping with disappointments, or developing a negative image of themselves as a pupil.

By contrast, one extra year of preparation can spare them much greater difficulties later on.

Myth 4: “He’s clever, so he should go to primary school”

Truth: Intelligence is only one part of school readiness.

A child may know letters and numbers or have an excellent vocabulary, and at the same time find it hard:

  • to wait their turn

  • to cope with frustration

  • to finish tasks

  • to follow rules

  • to organise their materials

  • to concentrate for long periods

Primary school demands far more than cognitive skills.

Myth 5: “He’ll get bored if he stays another year”

Truth: A child who needs to repeat a year usually doesn’t get bored.

Instead, they use the extra time to develop skills that are still maturing.

What’s more, a second year in kindergarten is never exactly the same as the first. The child approaches activities from a different developmental stage, often takes on a more active role in the group and gains greater self-confidence.

Myth 6: “It will affect him psychologically”

Truth: A child who fails at school every day is usually affected far more than a child who is given the time they need.

Constantly experiencing difficulty can lead to:

  • anxiety

  • low self-esteem

  • school refusal

  • a sense of inadequacy

When it is done for the right reasons, repeating a year often protects the child’s mental health.

Myth 7: “He’ll be stigmatised”

Truth: Adults usually worry about this far more than children themselves do.

At a young age, children are mainly interested in:

  • play

  • friendships

  • being part of the group

When parents and teachers present repeating a year in a positive and natural way, children usually accept it without much difficulty.

Myth 8: “If he stays back a year, he’s bound to mature”

Truth: Repeating a year is not a magic solution on its own.

The extra year needs to be put to meaningful use.

When there are difficulties in areas such as:

  • speech and communication

  • attention

  • motor skills

  • social skills

  • emotional regulation

it is important that appropriate support from specialists is also provided where needed.

Myth 9: “Let him go to primary school, and if he struggles, we’ll see”

Truth: Prevention is usually better than repair.

When difficulties are already visible, a “we’ll see how it goes” approach can lead to a difficult first experience of school.

The first image a child forms of themselves as a pupil has a significant impact on their future attitude towards school and learning.

Myth 10: “Most children manage in the end”

Truth: It’s true that many children do manage to adapt.

The question, however, is not whether they will manage eventually.

The question is: how much anxiety, how much effort and how many negative experiences will it take for them to get there?

What can repeating a year offer?

Repeating a year can give the child:

  • more time to mature emotionally

  • better development of attention and concentration

  • stronger language skills

  • improved social skills

  • greater independence

  • better self-regulation

  • a boost in self-confidence

  • a more positive first experience of primary school

  • a better chance of success at school

  • less anxiety and frustration

So, does the child lose or gain?

Repeating a year is not a decision to be taken lightly. Every child is unique and needs an individual assessment.

But when it is recommended by specialists, it is worth seeing it differently:

The child doesn’t lose a year.

They gain a year of maturing.

They gain a year of self-confidence.

They gain a year of experiencing success.

They gain a year to build solid foundations.

And often, that one year can have a positive effect not only on Year 1 of primary school, but on their entire school career.

Because in children’s development, the goal is not to reach the destination first. It is to arrive ready to enjoy it.

Carola Folle-Alepi Clinical Psychologist MSc – Child Psychologist – Speech and Language Therapist Director of the Centre for Child and Adult Development and Psychotherapy

Blog

What's on our minds

Articles on development, relationships and mental health at every age.

All articles
ΕΣΠΑ 2021–2027 — Πρόγραμμα «Πελοπόννησος»