For parents to be consistent, they need to be sure themselves that what they are doing is right. Otherwise, they are not convincing enough and the message the child receives is confusing.
It is also very important for parents to work as a team, with a shared approach to how they behave, so that they avoid the “good cop, bad cop” game and do not allow the child to play one parent off against the other to get what they want and make the other look like the “bad guy”. By standing firmly by a joint decision and handling things together, parents show their children that they both care equally and share the same view, and they more easily persuade the children to think about the actual issue that has come up rather than about whose side to win over. In this way, parents become role models of cooperation and mutuality for their children, and do not pass on messages of rivalry, secrets and alliances within the family.
“Good” boundaries are characterised by:
1. Consistency
Boundaries must be consistent and always upheld, otherwise children do not link their actions to the consequences and responsibilities that follow from them, but to their parents’ mood and bad temper. By setting consistent boundaries, parents build, in the long run, a climate of safety and security in the child’s relationship with them, because the child learns that they can rely on their parents and have them as a steady point of reference. In the long term, the gain for the child is that they adopt a responsible attitude, which enables them to set their own boundaries, make decisions of their own accord and, more generally, define who they are.
If boundaries are not consistent and the child learns that one way or another they can get around them, parents make every future “attempt” to set boundaries more painful both for themselves and for their child. Once the child has experienced that it is within their power to overcome the limit their parents have set, as long as they apply enough pressure, next time they will try even harder and more persistently to succeed. That is why parents should not “try” to set boundaries, but should be convinced and determined to do so. They will pass this inner attitude on to their child, who in turn will accept the situation more easily.
Even when rules are set consistently, parents should not expect the child to follow them perfectly straight away. For quite some time the child will test whether the boundary really holds, as if checking whether the “banisters” – the parents – on the child’s “developmental staircase” are sturdy and will hold. Parents should also bear in mind that a child does not have the same emotional maturity or the same developed logical thinking as an adult, nor much life experience. The child will try many times to do what satisfies them and will try countless times to overstep the limits their parents have set, because they act more on impulse and emotion. What is more, when boundaries are first applied, children will probably react more intensely than before – they will shout, cry and use every bit of manipulation they have against their parents, and they will say things they know are hurtful (“I don’t love you at all”, “I’m going to find another mum”). Of course, they don’t mean any of what they say, nor, during such an outburst, are they in a position to listen to their parents or discuss the matter. For this reason, it would be good for parents to ignore this behaviour and talk about it once things have calmed down. Otherwise, all parents will achieve is to prolong the tension, because getting their parents’ attention straight away acts as a strong reinforcement of the child’s unwanted behaviour.
2. Clarity
Boundaries must be clear, specific and expressed plainly. The child must know exactly which behaviour is acceptable and which is not, as well as when, how and under what circumstances we expect a particular behaviour. Parents should explain the boundary they are setting when they are on good terms with the child, not at the moment they are dealing with the issue. They should be calm, make sure they have the child’s attention, and ensure there is no tension and nothing around that might distract them.
Example: “I will read you the story if you have put on your pyjamas and brushed your teeth by eight o’clock. After that, unfortunately, I can’t read you the story, because it will be time for you to go to sleep.”
When setting boundaries, parents need to make sure that their non-verbal messages match their verbal ones, because otherwise the child receives a “double message” that confuses them and makes cooperation harder. A child receives double messages when, for example, a parent states a boundary in a hesitant voice, as a question or without conviction, if their body language conveys insecurity, or if they are not looking at the child but at someone else for “support”.
When parents set boundaries, they should stick to the “here and now” principle, without references to the past and without predictions about the future, such as “You hit the other children at the last birthday party too” or “You’ll never learn this”.
3. Everyone wins (“win-win”)
Boundaries take into account and respect the needs of everyone they affect. Parents should make it a principle to find solutions so that both they and the child get what they want, wherever possible, or to find alternatives.
Example: The parent could allow the child to use the stereo once the child has shown they know how to handle it properly, and they could agree on the conditions under which it may be used (e.g. with the parent present). Setting a boundary should also include making clear the consequences of not respecting it, which are usually simply the absence of positive consequences – for example, losing use of the stereo.
4. Prevention
Boundaries are set in order to prevent problems and difficult situations. Therefore, we should set them before problems arise or before a situation gets worse.
Example:
“Now that we’re going to Georgie’s party, I expect you to ...... If you ….. unfortunately we’ll have to leave the party.”
5. They are positive
Effective boundaries are expressed in a positive way and focus on positive outcomes. They are expressed as promises, warnings and information, not as threats.
Example:
“If you tidy up the things in your room by 7 o’clock, we’ll have time to go for a walk to the square.”
6. Follow-through
We allow a positive consequence to happen only when the child does what we have agreed / set.
7. Boundaries appropriate to the child’s age, stage of development and personality.
Very young children (up to about 2 years old) act mainly spontaneously and emotionally. They do not yet have the cognitive maturity to grasp the consequences of their actions, they cannot see a situation from someone else’s point of view, and they cannot reconsider and change what they are doing when something attracts them. At this age, when a child shows “mild” unwanted behaviour (e.g. lightly pushing another child), the most effective response is to guide them straight away towards the desired solution. The other child has already shown distress, something a child understands immediately. What the child does not understand is why the other child reacted by crying, since the aim was to have fun. In this case, the parent would do well to show the child what an alternative, positive behaviour would look like – for example, stroking the other child instead of pushing them. With dangerous behaviour (climbing on furniture, deliberately biting hard), the parent needs to adopt a serious manner, prevent the dangerous behaviour or stop it decisively with a firm “no”, and then guide the child towards a desired behaviour, preferably a variation of the unwanted one.
With children aged 2 and over, setting boundaries should always be accompanied by an explanation of why they are being set. From the age of about two and a half, a child has a greater sense of the consequences of their actions and learns to control their behaviour, accept rules, express their feelings in a healthy way, avoid dangers and, more generally, become more responsible.
As the child grows, boundaries need to be continually adjusted to their developmental level and to the abilities they have acquired. Parents should make sure they widen their boundaries so that the child can make age-appropriate choices, and is therefore able, in adolescence, to make sound decisions and constructive choices about their life.
Boundaries should be reasonable, not excessive, and should not hold the child back in their development (“limits to limits”). Parents should also ask themselves whether a particular issue might simply be a quirk of their own that they need to reconsider.
Boundaries appropriate to the “seriousness” of the situation. Parents have to set limits on behaviours that differ in intensity, seriousness and the impact they have on the child’s surroundings and development. Some of a child’s behaviours may lead to situations that are dangerous for the child or for others. Other reactions may cause upheaval within the family, and with others the child may claim excessive rights for their age or a disproportionate role within the “family system”. Parents therefore need to prioritise issues according to their seriousness and to how the family functions, and set boundaries accordingly.
Blog
What's on our minds
Articles on development, relationships and mental health at every age.
All articles








